Barstool Sports Founder Dave Portnoy’s $42 M Home in Nantucket, MA

Written By

Sophia Chen

Updated on

Sophia Chen

Meet Sophia Chen, the boss editor at Crazy Luxury Homes! She’s the one picking out the coolest houses for you. Sophia turns homes into stories, making sure each one is a must-see.

Front of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Sanford & Sanford Real Estate

Nestled in the exclusive Monomoy Harbor, Dave Portnoy’s newly acquired estate redefines luxury and exclusivity on Nantucket Island.

Spanning 1.2 acres, the property, which includes two homes, has set a new state record at $42 million, making it the most expensive residential purchase in Massachusetts history.

Situated in a neighborhood known for attracting billionaires and celebrities, the estate blends coastal charm with modern opulence, becoming a symbol of grandeur.

Indoor-Outdoor Masterpiece

At the heart of the estate lies a 5,200-square-foot main house, designed to blur the boundaries between indoor and outdoor living.

Floor-to-ceiling accordion glass walls open up to 180-degree views of the harbor, Nantucket town, and the sparkling waters of Nantucket Sound.

Each room is bathed in natural light, allowing residents to enjoy panoramic vistas from sunrise to sunset.

With multiple bedrooms, this home offers a perfect balance of sophistication and comfort, while expansive living areas are ideal for both intimate gatherings and large-scale entertaining.

A Luxurious Guest House

Perched on a hill behind the main residence, the two-bedroom guest house serves as a luxurious retreat with the same attention to detail and design as the main home.

From its elevated position, guests are treated to sweeping views of the harbor, infinity pool, and lush surroundings, providing an intimate yet private space for visitors.

The Private Beachfront Retreat

Boasting 140 feet of private beach, this estate offers the perfect backdrop for oceanfront living.

Whether for a leisurely swim or a scenic boat ride, the beach is an invitation to embrace the natural beauty of the Atlantic.

The infinity pool, designed to capture the island’s iconic sunsets, provides a serene escape with uninterrupted views stretching over the harbor.

Unparalleled Outdoor Spaces

The estate’s outdoor areas are meticulously crafted for both relaxation and entertainment.

Perfectly positioned for spectacular views of the July 4th fireworks, starlit nights, and ferries sailing past Brant Point, the outdoor spaces are as functional as they are breathtaking.

This is more than just a home—it’s a lifestyle, offering the ultimate Nantucket experience.

A Harborfront Elegance

Designed by the renowned Andrew Kotchen of Workshop/APD and constructed by Reid Builders, this estate encapsulates the essence of harborfront living.

Combining natural beauty with architectural brilliance, this Monomoy retreat stands as a rare opportunity to experience the finest that Nantucket has to offer.

Scroll down to see stunning photos of this property.

Photos of Dave Portnoy’s Home

The front of the house features three dormer windows and a welcoming entryway underneath a clear blue sky.

Exterior of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

An aerial view of the property reveals its stunning location nestled in greenery, with a private path leading directly to the beach, surrounded by other luxurious estates.

Aerial View of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Read McKendree

A sleek outdoor lounge area features stylish sun loungers beneath a pergola, with a view of the harbor and distant pier, creating a relaxing setting.

Outdoor Lounge of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Read McKendree

The master bedroom opens directly to a private outdoor space, featuring large glass doors that offer a seamless transition between indoor and outdoor living.

Outdoor Space of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Read McKendree

Sitting on a large, beautifully manicured lawn overlooking the harbor, the house offers panoramic water views that stretch out to the horizon.

Aerial View of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow
Aerial View of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

A wooden deck wraps around the back of the house, ideal for enjoying views of the serene harbor and the boats anchored in the distance.

Deck of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

Leading to the front door, a neatly trimmed hedge archway adds privacy and charm to the entryway, with a classic brick pathway lined by vibrant plants.

Archway of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

A cozy outdoor seating area on the wooden deck provides an uninterrupted view of the sparkling blue waters of Nantucket Sound.

Outdoor Seating of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow
Outdoor Seating of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

Weaving through the coastal grasses, a private boardwalk leads directly to the property’s exclusive 140 feet of sandy beach.

Boardwalk of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

Framed by neatly trimmed hedges, the side view of the house provides both privacy and a quaint coastal aesthetic, with glimpses of the harbor in the background.

Exterior of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

An elevated viewpoint showcases the harbor dotted with sailboats, offering a peaceful backdrop for this waterfront property.

Aerial View of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

A stunning aerial view of the property highlights its prime location right on Monomoy Harbor, with a wide circular driveway and a garage tucked on the side.

Aerial View of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

The wooden deck in the backyard overlooks a lush green lawn that seamlessly blends into the natural surroundings with the calm harbor just beyond.

Deck of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

Featuring large picture windows, the back of the house provides uninterrupted views of the expansive green yard and the water, creating an ideal coastal retreat.

Rear View of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

A private sandy path lined with coastal grasses leads directly from the house to the property’s 140 feet of secluded beachfront.

Coastal View of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

The coastal greenery and dunes frame the shoreline, giving the property an unspoiled natural charm while overlooking Monomoy Harbor.

Greenery of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

A scenic view of the nearby dock extending into the harbor, with boats gently floating on the water, complements the home’s prime waterfront setting.

Dock of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow
Dock of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow
Dock of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

Designed for relaxation, with elegant lounge seating and a view of the harbor, a luxurious pool area captures the perfect balance between modern amenities and natural beauty.

Pool in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Sanford & Sanford Real Estate

The backyard boasts an inviting outdoor dining space under a pergola, with a large swimming pool and lounge area that offer a relaxing spot to take in the ocean views.

Backyard of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

A beautifully set outdoor table overlooks lush greenery and the harbor, offering a peaceful setting with soft evening light glinting off the water in the distance.

Outdoor Table of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

The sun sets over the harbor, reflecting off the large windows of the house and illuminating the modern pergola and cozy outdoor seating area.

Backyard of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

Showcasing a perfectly balanced design with expansive glass doors, the back of the house is a spacious patio, offering multiple seating areas.

Rear of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

The home is set against lush landscaping, with its clean architectural lines and multiple outdoor patios blending seamlessly into the natural surroundings.

Aerial View of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Instagram | NANTUCKET CURRENT

Glowing under string lights, with a pergola offering shade by day and ambiance by night, the outdoor dining space complements the serene poolside setting.

Backyard of Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Instagram | NANTUCKET CURRENT

Grand Interiors

The living room features large windows that fill the space with natural light and offer beautiful views of the harbor, complemented by hardwood floors and coastal decor.

Living Room in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

A cozy sitting area by the fireplace offers a comfortable space with wicker chairs and nautical accents, creating a warm, inviting atmosphere with water views.

Sitting Area in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

The open-concept living space flows into the dining area, featuring a striped couch with cheerful pillows and a rustic dining table, perfect for casual coastal living.

Living Room in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Zillow

Offering a stunning harbor view through large glass doors framed by soft curtains, the cozy living room features a decorative telescope, creating a seamless connection to the outdoors.

Living Room in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

The modern kitchen opens to an outdoor dining space, with a sleek island and a large chandelier providing a stylish touch, all overlooking a comfortable patio with a fireplace.

Kitchen in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

A serene dining area bathed in natural light features a modern wood table and sleek chairs, complemented by floor-to-ceiling windows with garden views.

Dining Area in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

Opening directly to the harbor, with accordion glass walls blurring the lines between indoor and outdoor living, a spacious bedroom creates a peaceful retreat.

Bedroom in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

A stylish staircase enclosed in rope-detailed railings adds a unique design element to the minimalist interior, enhancing the home’s modern aesthetic.

Stairs in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

Featuring a cozy bed with a textured throw, a beautifully designed bedroom boasts a natural wood nightstand and a rustic mirror.

Bedroom in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

The bathroom showcases a sleek design with a concrete sink and a glass-enclosed shower, featuring stylish herringbone tile and modern fixtures for a sophisticated feel.

Bathroom in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: One Kindesign

A spacious living room bathed in natural light features floor-to-ceiling windows and cozy, plush seating with modern hanging light fixtures.

Living Room in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Read McKendree

The living area boasts a central suspended fireplace, with expansive windows framing uninterrupted harbor views, creating a serene yet luxurious atmosphere.

Living Room in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Read McKendree

Elegantly designed with dual sinks, sleek marble finishes, and modern fixtures, the bathroom offers a spa-like retreat.

Bathroom in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Read McKendree

The open-plan kitchen and dining area features a marble island and built-in seating, combining modern design with functional elegance.

Open Plan in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Read McKendree

A cozy sitting room offers direct access to a balcony with sweeping views of the harbor, framed by chic French doors.

Sitting Room in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Read McKendree

Accented by deep blue sectional seating and patterned ottomans, with a modern shelving system, a cozy lounge area adds warmth and style to the room.

Lounge in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Instagram | NANTUCKET CURRENT

Framed by large windows that offer views of the surrounding greenery, with a long dining table and plush leather chairs, a stylish dining area creates an inviting atmosphere.

Dining Area in Dave Portnoy's Massachusetts Home
Image Credit: Instagram | NANTUCKET CURRENT

For inquiries regarding copyright, credit, or removal, please contact us using our contact form.

If you enjoyed this sneak peek into luxury homes, “SHARE” and help us spread the inspiration.

Leave a Comment