Mike Jeffries’ Former $29.5M Water Mill Estate Linked to Abuse Charges

Written By

Sophia Chen

Updated on

Sophia Chen

Meet Sophia Chen, the boss editor at Crazy Luxury Homes! She’s the one picking out the coolest houses for you. Sophia turns homes into stories, making sure each one is a must-see.

Gardens of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Former Abercrombie & Fitch CEO Mike Jeffries has been arrested on trafficking and interstate solicitation charges, stemming from alleged events at his former Hamptons residence.

This sprawling property, sold for $28 million in 2021, is now a focal point in the case against Jeffries and his partner, Matthew Smith, who face charges of exploiting dozens of men.

Court documents outline claims of abuse occurring at the estate, where luxurious living masked darker activities.

Jeffries, 80, and Smith, 61, along with a third individual, have been formally charged following a lengthy investigation.

Allegations of Abuse at the Estate

Prosecutors allege that the former CEO and Smith orchestrated a trafficking operation at the estate, recruiting men under false pretenses to participate in inappropriate acts.

Charges include claims of abuse spanning several years, involving dozens of victims.

Testimonies from accusers, including David Bradberry and Barrett Pall, describe being coerced into non-consensual acts at events held at the mansion, revealing a troubling aspect of the estate’s history.

Over 100 men were allegedly lured to the Water Mill estate under the guise of modeling opportunities, only to find themselves facing exploitation.

The Ongoing Legal Battle

The charges against Jeffries and his co-defendants have drawn significant media attention.

A class-action lawsuit, spearheaded by Bradberry, seeks justice for over 100 men who claim to have been exploited.

Jeffries’ attorney has stated that the defense plans to address the allegations in court, rather than through the media.

The Enduring Controversy

Jeffries, who led Abercrombie & Fitch from 1992 to 2014, was a controversial figure during his tenure.

His leadership revived the brand’s image but also attracted criticism for alleged discrimination and the influence of his partner, Smith, on company decisions.

Now, with these grave allegations, the former CEO faces legal and public scrutiny, casting a shadow over his legacy.

The luxurious Water Mill estate, once a symbol of Hampton’s opulence, now serves as a stark reminder of the alleged crimes that occurred within its walls.

The Lavish Water Mill Residence

The former CEO’s Hamptons estate, situated in the prestigious Water Mill area, spans nearly seven acres.

This estate boasts over 12,000 square feet of living space and was built to the highest standards, epitomizing opulent Hamptons living.

Surrounded by farmland on three sides and bordered by Mecox Bay on the fourth, the property offers the utmost privacy and scenic views.

The house itself was meticulously constructed over five years, completed in 2008, and features a traditional shingle-style design that harmonizes with classic English gardens.

Luxurious Amenities

Inside, the mansion combines modern conveniences with old-world charm.

A two-story library with a fireplace serves as a dramatic entrance.

The expansive living room, adorned with three sets of French doors, opens onto a covered porch, creating a seamless flow between indoor and outdoor spaces.

This home also includes a formal dining room, a smoking room, a chef’s kitchen, and an attached guest cottage with its own living quarters.

The estate’s exterior is equally impressive, featuring a heated gunite pool lined by an allée of sycamore trees, a carriage house, and expansive rose gardens.

A scenic path leads to a private dock on Mecox Bay, providing access for motorboats and kayaks.

The property’s craftsmanship and attention to detail exemplify luxury, creating an idyllic retreat.

Photos of the Estate

At dusk, the mansion radiates elegance, as the warm glow of sunset bathes the lush gardens and ivy-clad stone facade in soft light.

Exterior of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Ivy gracefully climbs the mansion’s exterior walls, accentuating the architectural detail and expansive windows that flood the interior with natural light.

Ivy-Covered Walls of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Surrounded by acres of greenery, the estate offers a private retreat with breathtaking views of rolling fields and distant landscapes.

Exterior of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The spacious lawn stretches out from the mansion, creating a perfect contrast against the lush ivy adorning the walls and numerous chimneys.

Lawn of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

A gravel pathway leads to the front entrance, framed by mature trees and verdant shrubbery, inviting a tranquil approach to the estate.

Pathway of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The meticulously planned garden, featuring symmetrical flower beds and pristine hedges, sits alongside a secluded swimming pool for added luxury.

Garden and Pool of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Positioned near a serene waterfront, the estate’s vast grounds offer uninterrupted views of the water and surrounding farmland.

Aerial View of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The shaded veranda provides a perfect outdoor seating area, allowing guests to relax while enjoying panoramic views of the estate’s expansive grounds.

Veranda of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

An inviting pergola extends from the house, draped with climbing vines and surrounded by lush grass, offering a charming outdoor living space.

Pergola of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The sprawling estate overlooks a picturesque landscape of water and fields, blending seamlessly into its natural surroundings with breathtaking views.

Landscape Views from  Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

An inviting covered patio features a stone fireplace surrounded by stacked wood, creating a cozy outdoor seating area perfect for cool evenings.

Patio of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Tall hedges border a serene rectangular pool, providing a private and tranquil setting amidst lush green lawns and perfectly aligned trees.

Pool Area of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The poolside lounging area offers a peaceful retreat, where rows of lounge chairs face the sunset, surrounded by well-manicured hedges and expansive grass.

Pool Area of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Shaded by towering trees, the tranquil pool is framed by a row of perfectly spaced trees and lush hedges, offering a secluded escape.

Pool Area of Mike Jeffries'  Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

French doors open to reveal an elegant living area with white sofas, leading to a balcony that offers expansive views of the lush landscape beyond.

Living Area in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

A refined sitting room with large bay windows bathes the space in natural light, offering an intimate setting with views of the verdant gardens.

Sitting Room in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The sophisticated living room combines comfort with style, featuring a fireplace, plush armchairs, and floor-to-ceiling windows that let in ample sunlight.

Living Area in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Dark-paneled walls and a crystal chandelier give the private library an air of classic elegance, while bookshelves provide ample space for an extensive collection.

Library in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The modern dining area with glass doors offers a seamless indoor-outdoor flow, where a large table comfortably seats eight, illuminated by abundant natural light.

Dining Area in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Intricate black-and-white wallpaper adds a touch of elegance to the dining room, where the glass-topped table reflects the soft glow of the nearby fireplace.

Dining Area in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The spacious living area exudes warmth with its inviting fireplace, surrounded by floor-to-ceiling windows that seamlessly connect the interior to the lush garden outside.

Living Area in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Featuring dark wood paneling, a glowing fireplace, and an upper balcony lined with shelves filled with books, the double-height library exudes a majestic atmosphere.

Library in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Large windows bathe the grand library in natural light, while sleek black shelves and a glass table create a modern yet cozy atmosphere.

Library in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

A hallway of bookshelves invites exploration, with rows of carefully arranged books leading to a spacious reading area lit by soft overhead lighting.

Hallway in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Loft-like studio offers expansive views through oversized windows, while minimalist design ensures the focus remains on the surrounding landscape.

Studio in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The gourmet kitchen gleams with polished stainless steel surfaces, showcasing a professional layout ideal for culinary enthusiasts, including hanging copper pots for a rustic touch.

Kitchen in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

This modern bedroom embraces simplicity with a sleek white bed and metallic reading lamps, contrasting beautifully against the dark textured walls.

Bedroom in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

Neutral tones dominate the second bedroom, where natural light filters through large windows, creating a serene space perfect for relaxation.

Bedroom in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The cozy bedroom features a red bedspread and floral armchairs by the fireplace, blending traditional decor with a comfortable, intimate ambiance.

Bedroom in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

A grand bedroom showcases dramatic vaulted ceilings, a cozy fireplace, and strategically positioned windows that offer sweeping views of the landscape.

Bedroom in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

The luxurious bathroom features floor-to-ceiling marble, a spacious glass shower, and expansive windows that flood the space with natural light while overlooking serene fields.

Bathroom in Mike Jeffries' Former NY Home
Image Credit: Tim Davis

For inquiries regarding copyright, credit, or removal, please contact us using our contact form.

If you enjoyed this sneak peek into luxury homes, “SHARE” and help us spread the inspiration.

Leave a Comment